Grade: B
Time it takes: 3 hours and 10-20 minutes (50 minutes prep, 2 hours slow cooking, 20-30 minutes baking)
Yield: Serves 4-6
Source: adapted from a recipe at cooks.com
Another inspired recipe from our wedding. Chris ordered the shepherd's pie for lunch at Epcot's Rose & Crown pub. It was the best shepherd's pie either of us have ever tasted - it made me wish I had ordered it as well instead of fish and chips. I tried to find the recipe for it online somewhere, but alas I could not. I knew that it was made with lamb, which if it is called shepherd's pie it is suppose to be made with lamb while it turns into cottage pie if it is made with beef (the internet told me so), and I knew it had carrots. Not really that helpful of information, but I searched for recipes that were traditional English recipes with lamb and carrots.
It was a tad annoying searching for shepherd's pie and coming up with cottage pie 85% of the time - people, name your dishes correctly! Cooks.com is not the most helpful recipe site either, and especially not for the particular recipe I found. All the comments were just random discussion of shepherd's pie vs cottage pie and cheese usage in international cuisine. There were pages on pages of that crap, and I did not find one useful post about the recipe...was it good? did anybody make any changes? any tips? Nothing! It was the most promising recipe I had found though, so I decided to make it.
I wanted to make individual shepherd's pies for everybody - there were six to feed. Along with the scotch eggs, I brought this to the British themed feast. The recipe I used did not have a serving size, so I doubled it and hoped for the best. I used little disposable foil dishes, and doubling the recipe was not enough to fill each with the amount I had desired. Atty and I evenly distributed all of the meat mixture into each and it worked, but I really wished it had been thicker. Next time, I would use the doubled amount and put it into just four dishes.
The shepherd's pie turned out quite tasty, but not as good as the one from Rose & Crown pub at Epcot. If I hadn't had the one from Rose & Crown I am pretty sure I would have loved the one I made, but I know it can be better. I think I need to head over to Epcot and butter up the chef for the recipe!
I am going to post the recipe exactly as I made, in the doubled amount.
Click below to expand for the recipe!